Showing posts with label Congressman Dennis Ross. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Congressman Dennis Ross. Show all posts

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Comparing Labor Cost Proportions at the USPS, UPS, and FedEx

Update: this chart in this post has been replaced to correct a silly error.  The USPS delivers to residential addresses 6 days a week.  I know that and I know that all readers of this blog know this as well.  I would like to thank the reader who posted the comment that force me to fix this error. 

In a discussion today on his Facebook page, Representative Dennis Ross fell into a common trap in comparing the labor's portion of costs by the USPS, UPS and FedEx.  He states that:

UPS (Union) - about 66% of their total operating costs are labor. FedEx (non-union) - about 45% of their total operating costs are labor. USPS - 80-82%.

The differences in the proportion of labor costs can come from one of six factors:
  1. Compensation levels - what each company pays per hour worked
  2. Work rules - affects how efficiently each company uses employees
  3. Contracting - companies use different models regarding the use of contractors to handle the collection to delivery process, and in particular the labor-intensive delivery function
  4. Network differences - Differences in the network affects the amount of labor involved in delivery, sortation, transportation and retail portions of an end-to-end movement.
  5. Capital intensity -  The companies have very different capital requirements that affect the amount of non-labor costs needed to provide the services that they offer.
  6. Congressional requirements - Congressional requirements focus on the aspects of the Postal Service that add significantly more labor costs while making minimal impact on capital spending.
Compensation Levels

I have already presented a comparison of compensation levels between the Postal Service, UPS, and FedEx.   The comparison showed that total compensation of Postal Service employees in a delivery function clearly fall in between the compensation of UPS and FedEx.  

Employees who work inside processing facilities at the Postal Service on average are paid more than FedEx and UPS employees.  However, the new APWU contract will result in Postal Service compensation falling in line with what compensation of UPS and FedEx.   (It should be noted that UPS also offers significant college scholarships as a benefit to parcel sorting employees that are not included in these comparisons.)  The compensation levels of the new class of APWU members that could include 20% of APWU employees are very competitive with compensation of individuals with similar experience at UPS and FedEx.

Employees that provide retail services at the Postal Service have no real comparison with employees at FedEx and UPS.  Comparisons are usually made here with other retail occupations and bank tellers.  I have not looked at this comparison but the data is available to make this comparison is available from both private and public sources.
Finally, compensation of UPS and FedEx executives are significantly higher than Postal Service executives.   The compensation levels of managers and technical staff at UPS and FedEx are likely also higher.

On balance, it is unclear how much a compensation premium affects labor compensation's proportion of total costs.

Work Rules

Another factor that increases USPS compensation expenses are work rules used for mail processing, local transportation and retail services.  The new APWU contract, and in particular the new method of defining a full time schedule should go far to eliminate work rules that requires the Postal Service to overstaff its processing and retail facilities.   The new method of defining full time will likely result in employee schedules that are close to the part time schedules that FedEx and UPS use for its sortation centers.

Contracting

The following table illustrates how the Postal Service, UPS and FedEx use contractors.  

Comparison of Contracting at the USPS, UPS, and FedEx

The three carriers have very different operating models that significantly affect the portion of costs that show up in expenses as "compensation and benefits" and "contracted transportation" This makes comparisons particularly difficult as both UPS and FedEx use contractors extensively for retail services and FedEx Ground uses contractors to deliver all parcels.
An accurate comparison would identify the labor component of contracted retail, transportation, and delivery services. This is nearly impossible and is the primary reason that I have never presented a comparison of the proportion of labor costs in my previously published analyses of the parcel industry.

Network Differences

The following chart looks at differences in the networks employed by the USPS, UPS and FedEx. 

 Comparison of USPS, UPS, and FedEx Networks
The Postal Service's delivery network is significantly more extensive than either UPS or FedEx and primarily delivers to residential addresses that are more expense to serve than business address due to volume of deliveries per delivery point.  Delivering 6-days to residential addresses increases the proportion of labor costs as capital expenses for buildings and vehicles are the same whether the Postal Service delivered 5 or 6 days per week, and some operating costs (heating fuel and electricity) do not change as much as labor costs. [added 5/23/2011 3:15 pm along with corrected chart] 
The Postal Service network has significant overcapacity.   To the extent that there is overcapacity in either UPS or FedEx's network it would affect short-term economic impacts or changes in population and economic growth across the United States.   Also both UPS and FedEx are face the prospects of growing volumes so they face some challenges of having sufficient capacity while the Postal Service faces shrinking volumes so its network faces the prospect of increasing levels of overcapacity and the prospect that over time existing facilities will be in sub-optimal locations.
The Postal Service's retail network focuses on less knowledgeable buyers of the services that it offers.  Also, the Postal Service's network faces regulatory and legislated constraints that neither UPS nor FedEx face.

Capital Intensity

Capital intensity affects the proportion of costs that are labor costs.  Companies that are more capital intense have a lower portion of labor compensation costs and vise versa.   For example, an electric utility is a more capital intense business than a nationwide retail chain.   The following chart illustrates differences in capital intensity between the delivery services offered by the USPS, UPS, and FedEx. 

Comparison of Capital Intensity of USPS, UPS and FedEx
FedEx has the most transportation capital needs as they operate the largest fleet of freighter airplanes in the United States. UPS has the second largest fleet of freighter airplanes. Both FedEx and UPS use their aircraft to fly Postal Service mail and parcels, relieving the Postal Service from making substantial capital investments.  The Postal Service's transportation needs focus on its delivery fleet.   However, it has not had the capital needed to replace its aging fleet, so its capital spending on transportation assets are below what may be required for cost-efficient operations.
Both FedEx and UPS are among the leaders in information technology spending among transportation companies.    They both look at their IT investments as a competitive advantage.   The Postal Service, on the other hand, has tended to underspend on information technology resulting in long implementation schedules for needed infrastructure, management information systems, customer information and transaction systems, and track and trace systems for mail and parcels.
Finally, both UPS and FedEx have managed their processing network using network models for years without constraints set by Congress on closing or moving operations.    When additional facilities are needed, or upgraded to ensure proper maintenance and worker safety, they have the resources to make these investments.   The Postal Service is limited to use the facilities that it now has and faces significant backlogs in facility maintenance.   To the extent that facilities are located in the wrong location, or too small to handle sortation of a larger geographic territory, the Postal Service does not have the capital to make those investments. 

Congressional Requirements

The Postal Service face two requirements from Congress that increase the labor cost's proportion of total costs.
  1. Restrictions on how retail services are provided -  Both regulatory and legal restrictions on the Postal Service's retail network increase the proportion of total costs that are labor costs.  These costs come from both operating a retail network and managing the process to implement changes in the network.     In addition, Congressional efforts to slow changes to the retail networks add additional labor costs to managing the network to handle questions and concerns of members of Congress.
  2. Restrictions on delivery frequency - Requiring the Postal Service to provide delivery services 6 days a week has a larger marginal impact on labor costs  than it does on all other expenses.   The proportion of labor costs would be lower if the Postal Service only delivered mail 5 days per week.
Conclusion

Comparing the proportion of labor costs at the Postal Service with the proportion of labor costs at FedEx and UPS is a nonsensical exercise.   It tells one little about what the appropriate proportion would be for an efficient or properly capitalized Postal Service. 

Focusing on unionized labor costs may be an easy political target for a Republican member of Congress. However, Congressman Dennis Ross would find his time better served if he now focused his time on examining, the Postal Service's financial goals, its capital structure and its real annual capital needs to replace the delivery fleet, optimize the network, modernize retail, upgrade the IT infrastructure and customer interfaces, and cover the transition costs of downsizing the workforce.   By making this shift, Congressman Ross would make a real contribution to postal reform.  His efforts would for the first time address one of the key failures of both the Postal Reorganization Act and the Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act, the failure to adequately recognize that "accounting break-even" is not an appropriate fiancial goal and that an under-capitalized Postal Service is an inefficient Postal Service.


Thursday, February 17, 2011

Tweets from Congressman Dennis Ross on the Postal Service

On February 17, 2011, Congressman Dennis Ross tweeted, " we will have a website where the man or woman on the street can tell us how to improve service and cut costs."

This is the first indication of what Congressman Ross wants to do as Government Reform Committee's Subcommittee on Federal Workers, the Postal Service and Labor Policy

Congress Dennis Ross Spoke on Postal Issues

On February 12,Congressman Dennis Ross tweeted "Speaking to the Letter Carriers installation dinner tonight in Lakeland. Going to speak the truth as I see it about the postal service."

Does anyone who follow this blog know what he said?  If you do, post a comment and/or e-mail me.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

What do House Republicans Think About Budget Changes Relating to the Postal Service?

Now that the President's 2012 budget is out, both Senator Tom Carper and Senator Susan Collins have already commented on the proposal to provide some modifications to the Postal Service's retirement obligations.   To date, members of the house who are leading the subcommittee responsible for marking up legislation that would enact the changes that the President proposed have made any public statement about their views on the proposed statements.

As both Representatives Dennis Ross (R-FL) and Justin Amash (R-MI) are freshmen,  they have no history with Postal issues and are more than likely coming to the issue with not much more background in the postal market than the average consumer.  Given their lack of experience with the issue, it is not surprising that they did not immediately respond to the budget as the Senators Carper and Collins did.

What we have to go on is their public statements so here is a review of quotes from articles and press releases that may provide some guidance.

Congressman Dennis Ross

Ed O'Keefe of the Washington Post interviewed Congressman Ross after he was appointed chairman of the Government Reform Committee's subcommittee on federal workers, the Postal Service and labor policy.  In that interview he honestly expressed that the issues before the subcommittee were new to him although he had proposed similar changes in the federal payroll during his campaign.

Ross noted that he proposed trimming the federal payroll through pay freezes or attrition during his campaign. His new role, he said, presents "an exciting opportunity to open up and look inside the workings of our federal workforce" and learn more on a topic about which he admits he knows little.

Later the article gave an impression as to how he plans to run the subcommittee

Ross's subcommittee will focus first on those proposals by gathering facts and not pushing "a hidden agenda," he said. "We want to ask a lot of questions, we want to get a lot of experts testifying before us, and we want to find out what it's going to take" to deliver benefits to active and retired federal employees in a cost-effective manner, Ross said.

Congressman Justin Amash

Congressman Amash has a bit more of a public record that is available from his press releases. In a jhttp://amash.house.gov/press-release/amash-selected-oversight-leadership following his appointment as Vice Chairman of Government Reform Committee's subcommittee on federal workers, the Postal Service and labor policy, he presented an initial position on postal issues:

"USPS has raised its rates in the last several years and now is threatening steep service cuts. I look forward to examining closely whether some of USPS's functions could be done more efficiently through competition and the private sector."

In a press release announcing his appointment to the Congress's Joint Economic Committee, Representative Amash stated, 

"I look forward to studying how the government’s expansion has inhibited our economic growth and how we can be champions of job creators.”

Finally, in a press release following the publication of the President's budget, Congressman Amash provides the following quote:

“Instead of fresh ideas and a bipartisan way forward, the proposed budget feeds Washington’s addiction to more taxes, more spending, and more debt.  The White House’s own projections show a ‘new normal’ of debt that we have not seen since we were fighting World War II."

“Americans expect more from their representatives, as well they should.  With four years in a row of trillion dollar deficits, the public demands that we be more than caretakers of a bloated federal bureaucracy.  They deserve more than token cuts.  They deserve a responsible government.

“I look forward to working with House leadership and my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to remove the debt burden from our children and future generations.”  

In sum,  these statements suggest that the Republicans leading the Government Reform Committee's subcommittee on federal workers, the Postal Service and labor policy are faced with looking at a signifiant change in postal law with a limited understanding of:
  • the postal market, 
  • the roll that the Postal Service plays in the economy and 
  • the challenges of turning around an enterprise as large as the Postal Service in a manner that does not disrupt the success of businesses, governments, and non-profit entities, including the campaigns they will likely run in another year that depend on the existence of a nationwide postal network. 
In all likelihood, both Congressman Ross and Amash will soon realize that gaining that understanding will take more effort than either of them envisioned when they were first appointed.